Why Market Volatility is Nothing New

Despite some extreme stock market moves, recent market performance hasn't been that far outside the norm, says Morningstar's Amy Arnott

Amy Arnott 30 May, 2022 | 3:00PM
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn

US stock market trader

A version of this article was originally published on February 7, 2022.

It's been a bumpy ride for investors so far in 2022. The Morningstar US Market index was down about 19% for the year to date on May 20, 2022, and previously high-flying areas such as growth stocks, technology companies, and momentum names have been particularly hard-hit. Nearly half of the underlying stocks in the Morningstar US Market Index – including widely held names such as Tesla (TSLA), Nvidia (NVDA), Facebook owner Meta Platforms (FB), and Netflix (NFLX) are now down 30% or more from their 52-week highs.

While broader market benchmarks have been more resilient, growth stocks have officially dipped into correction territory: the Morningstar Small, Mid, and Large Growth indices were all down about 30% for the year to date. Although the year is off to a more volatile than usual start, the recent market jitters aren't completely unheard of. In this article, I'll look at current market volatility relative to previous norms and suggest some ways for investors to cope.

As the chart below shows, volatility has been on an upward trend. The CBOE VIX index, which measures market expectations for equity-market volatility based on index options for the S&P 500, has trended up after a relatively quiet summer. Markets have been shaken by a few different things: ongoing worries about new coronavirus variants, political instability in Eastern Europe, the sudden resurgence of inflation, and fears that rising interest rates could put a damper on future equity valuations. As a result, the VIX has recently spiked into the high 20s, compared with a long-term average of about 19.3.

Actual volatility has also increased. After an unusually quiet year during most of 2021, the standard deviation (a measure of volatility) for the Morningstar US Market Index has also started trending higher. The standard deviation stood at 16.10% for the trailing 12-month period to April 30, 2022, compared with 10.77% for calendar 2021.

This volatility has also translated into more frequent losses. Since the market started getting more jittery in November 2021, about half of all trading days have closed with market losses. The number of trading days with losses of 1% or more has also increased slightly.

It's All Relative

When looked at in the context of longer-term historical averages, though, recent market performance hasn't been that far outside the norm. As the table below illustrates, market losses are actually pretty common. About 45% of trading days finish with negative returns. Losses are less frequent with longer periods, but still relatively common. About 42% of weekly trading periods have historically ended with negative returns, and about a third of all monthly trading periods have finished up in the red. Over longer periods, annual returns have been negative about one fourth of the time.*

Losses are part of the territory, performance table

Recent market volatility hasn't been too far outside the usual range. Since November 2021, there have been 73 trading days (out of 203) with negative returns, but only 11 of those days have closed with losses greater than 2%. Volatility probably seems higher partly because we've experienced some more-dramatic intraday swings; in addition, growth stocks have suffered much more frequent and severe losses.

Some investors might also be alarmed by recent market turmoil simply because we haven't seen much of it in the recent past. The novel coronavirus-driven bear market in early 2020 was unusually swift and severe but also surprisingly short-lived. After dropping about 34% from February 19 to March 23, 2020, stocks surged ahead to make a full recovery by August. After the 2020 rebound, 2021 proved to be another temperate year for equity investors.

Market volatility was well below average, with a standard deviation about 20% below the long-term historical average for the year. With a few exceptions (such as the tech, media, and telecom correction that started in 2000, the global financial crisis in 2008, and pandemic-driven uncertainty in early 2020), market volatility was also generally below average over the three previous decades. Based on past history, periodic market downturns are entirely normal and to be expected.

Over longer time periods, the market tends to be self-correcting; certain areas may get frothy and reach bubble status, and overall market valuations may overshoot the mark, but periodic downturns are a way of correcting for the excess. Heading into 2022, the overall market was trading at a 5% premium to the aggregate fair value estimated by Morningstar's equity analysts. After the recent drop, valuations are now looking more reasonable.

The Road Ahead Might Remain Bumpy

While valuation risk looks like less of an issue, there's no guarantee that market turmoil will settle down in the short term. It's a cliche to say that we're living in unprecedented times, but we really are in a period of flux and regime change. The previous 30 years (1991-2020) were generally marked by declining interest rates and benign inflation, creating a favourable environment for both stocks and bonds. But both measures are now reversing course. After running well below average for several years, inflation has recently been running at a 7% annualised rate, its highest level in the past 40 years. The Federal Reserve has signalled that it expects to begin raising interest rates later this year to keep inflation under control and yields on the 10-year Treasury bond have already edged up in response.

A fundamental regime change for both interest rates and inflation would have far-reaching implications for many asset classes, and it could take a while for the market to adapt to conditions that are far different from what most investors have grown up with. Indeed, many previously long-running trends have already made dramatic reversals over the past several months. Market leadership has flipped from growth to value; from tech stocks to energy, commodities, and other sectors; and from momentum names to tamer factors such as value, yield, and low volatility. And as both stocks and bonds have slid, the previously stalwart 60/40 portfolio has recently captured more of the downside than we've been accustomed to in recent decades.

What it Means for Your Portfolio

It's also important to keep in mind that, while market turmoil can be unpleasant, it ultimately doesn't matter too much for most long-term investors. (Sequence of returns risk is the exception, because an adverse sequence of returns puts retirees at risk of depleting their portfolios early in retirement and later missing out on an eventual rebound.) Far greater is the risk of permanent capital loss, or the risk of not meeting your long-term financial goals. As Christine Benz covered in a recent article, investors unsettled by market turbulence might want to take as step back to see whether their original investment plans still make sense. If you're approaching retirement, for example, you might need to de-risk your portfolio to mitigate the risk of starting to make withdrawals during an adverse sequence of returns.

If you'll need to tap into your portfolio within the few years (to pay for bigger expenses such as a deposit on a house or education fees) or if you're tempted to sell if things get worse, those can also be legitimate reasons to reconsider your portfolio's asset mix. But if your portfolio's asset mix is still a good fit for your time horizon and ability to take on risk, it's best to tune out the noise and avoid making any major changes: keep calm and carry on.

*Note: Daily, weekly, and monthly figures are based on total returns for the Morningstar U.S. Market Index starting in 1992. Annual figures are based on total returns for the IA SBBI Large Stock Index starting in 1926.

The information contained within is for educational and informational purposes ONLY. It is not intended nor should it be considered an invitation or inducement to buy or sell a security or securities noted within nor should it be viewed as a communication intended to persuade or incite you to buy or sell security or securities noted within. Any commentary provided is the opinion of the author and should not be considered a personalised recommendation. The information contained within should not be a person's sole basis for making an investment decision. Please contact your financial professional before making an investment decision.

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn

About Author

Amy Arnott  Amy Arnott