Head to Head: Should I Buy Tesla or Google?

Both may be mega-cap growth stocks, but only one is undervalued today

Susan Dziubinski 16 February, 2022 | 9:54AM
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn

Wrestling

We’re pitting Alphabet (Google) and Tesla against each other to determine which is the better investment opportunity today. Who wins this stock-versus-stock cage match? That depends on what Morningstar metrics matter most to you. Let’s look at how they stack up. 

Exhibit 1

Price/Fair Value Winner: Alphabet

Morningstar’s analysts calculate a fair value estimate for each stock they cover. The fair value estimate represents the intrinsic value of a stock, based on how much cash we think the company can generate in the future. A stock’s price/fair value is simply its current market price divided by the fair value estimate. A stock trading below 1.0 is undervalued; a stock trading around 1.0 is fairly valued; and a stock trading above 1.0 is overvalued.

At the time of writing (15 February), we think Alphabet is about 25% undervalued, while Tesla is 23% overvalued. The winner from a price perspective is Alphabet; it is trading at a more attractive price today.

Uncertainty Winner: Alphabet

Morningstar's uncertainty rating represents the predictability of the company's future cash flows and, therefore, the level of certainty we have in our fair value estimate. Companies that enjoy sales predictability, modest operating and financial leverage, and limited exposure to contingent events carry low uncertainty; those with less predictable sales, significant leverage, and significant exposure to contingent events carry higher uncertainty.

Our analysts think Alphabet’s cash flow uncertainty is high – but Tesla’s uncertainty is even higher. Alphabet wins for its relatively lower uncertainty because we’re more confident in our fair value estimate of that stock.

Economic Moat Winner: Alphabet

The Morningstar Economic Moat Rating describes a company's sustainable competitive advantage. A company with an economic moat can fend off competition and earn high returns on capital for many years to come. A company whose competitive advantages we expect to last more than 20 years has a wide moat, while one that can fend off its rivals for 10 years has a narrow moat. A firm with either no advantage or one that we think will quickly dissipate has no moat at all.

Our analysts think Alphabet has carved out a wide economic moat, while Tesla has only built a narrow economic moat. Alphabet for the win on this metric.

Capital Allocation Winner: Tie

The Morningstar Capital Allocation Rating represents our assessment of how well a company manages its balance sheet, investments, and shareholder distributions. Analysts assign each company one of three ratings – Exemplary, Standard, or Poor – based on their assessments of how well a management team provides shareholder returns. Adept corporate managers can make a good company even better.

Both Alphabet and Tesla earn our top rating when it comes to capital allocation, so that one ends on a tie.

Overall Winner: Alphabet

At the end of the day, the “winner” of any cage match from Morningstar’s perspective is the stock that’s trading at the largest discount to our fair value estimate after being adjusted for uncertainty. The Morningstar Rating for stocks conveys just that. Stocks rated four and five stars are undervalued after being adjusted for uncertainty; stocks rated three stars are fairly valued, and stocks rated one or two stars are overvalued.

At the moment, Alphabet earns a four-star rating, while Tesla earns a two-star rating. Alphabet therefore is the much better value today from Morningstar’s perspective.

The information contained within is for educational and informational purposes ONLY. It is not intended nor should it be considered an invitation or inducement to buy or sell a security or securities noted within nor should it be viewed as a communication intended to persuade or incite you to buy or sell security or securities noted within. Any commentary provided is the opinion of the author and should not be considered a personalised recommendation. The information contained within should not be a person's sole basis for making an investment decision. Please contact your financial professional before making an investment decision.

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn

Securities Mentioned in Article

Security NamePriceChange (%)Morningstar
Rating
Alphabet Inc Class A2,291.44 USD1.16Rating
Alphabet Inc Class C2,304.27 USD1.16Rating
Tesla Inc695.20 USD-0.57Rating

About Author

Susan Dziubinski  Susan Dziubinski is senior product manager with Morningstar.com.