Are These Funds Closet Trackers?

THE INCOME INVESTOR: If you are searching for yield, are you better off buying an exchange traded fund weighted by dividend, or buying an actively managed fund?

Emma Wall 17 June, 2014 | 5:04PM
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn

Income investors; are you better off holding a tracker or paying for active management?  The 10 largest stocks in the FTSE 100 are:

  1. Royal Dutch Shell (RDSB)
  2. HSBC (HSBA)
  3. BP (BP.)
  4. BHP Billiton (BLT)
  5. Unilever (ULVR)
  6. Diageo (DGE)
  7. GlaxoSmithKline (GSK)
  8. British American Tobacco (BATS)
  9. Rio Tinto (RIO)
  10. AstraZeneca (AZN)

 

If you invested in a market cap weighted exchange traded fund a sizable proportion of your money will be allocated into those top 10 stocks. You would be looking at an attractive level of income too – Shell yields 4.5%, BP yields 4.6% and BHP is yielding 3.9%. Attractive when you consider the recent fall in inflation to 1.5%.

In order to invest in these holdings – in order of market cap – you will typically pay less than 0.5%. But the average UK equity income fund manager will charge 1% or more; so it pays to make sure you are getting a truly actively managed portfolio.

Using the Morningstar X-Ray tool, which allows you to examine the underlying stocks in a portfolio, we created a portfolio made up of the 19 top-rated UK equity income funds. These included Artemis Income, Invesco Perpetual Income, Threadneedle UK Equity Alpha Income and Schroder Income among others. We then X-rayed the selection and revealed that the 10 most held stocks in the top-rated UK equity income funds are:

  1. GlaxoSmithKline
  2. AstraZeneca
  3. Royal Dutch Shell
  4. BP          
  5. BT (BT.A)
  6. Imperial Tobacco (IMT)
  7. HSBC
  8. Legal & General (LGEN)
  9. British American Tobacco
  10. BAE Systems (BA.)

 

The anomalies in the list are BT, which is the 23rd largest stock in the FTSE 100, Imperial Tobacco, which lists at 24th, Legal & General at 36th and BAE Systems is the 37th largest stock. These added extras suggest that active managers are adding value - but as these are the aggregated top 10, the seven out of 10 overlap should act as a warning to investors who don't look under the bonnet of a fund before buying.

For those investors who are disappointed by the similarities between the actively managed UK equity income funds and the FTSE 100, may wish to look at passive managment.

Exchange traded funds tracking the FTSE 100 are not just compiled by market cap. Strategic beta ETF iShares UK Dividend UCITS (IUKD) offers exposure to the 50 highest yielding UK stocks in the FTSE 350. The top 10 stocks in this ETF are a lot more diverse and has a yield of 4%.

The information contained within is for educational and informational purposes ONLY. It is not intended nor should it be considered an invitation or inducement to buy or sell a security or securities noted within nor should it be viewed as a communication intended to persuade or incite you to buy or sell security or securities noted within. Any commentary provided is the opinion of the author and should not be considered a personalised recommendation. The information contained within should not be a person's sole basis for making an investment decision. Please contact your financial professional before making an investment decision.

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn

Securities Mentioned in Article

Security NamePriceChange (%)Morningstar
Rating
Artemis Income R Inc2.34 GBP-0.09Rating
AstraZeneca PLC10,826.00 GBX-0.81Rating
BAE Systems PLC1,300.50 GBX1.05Rating
BP PLC508.50 GBX-0.76Rating
British American Tobacco PLC2,291.50 GBX-0.07Rating
BT Group PLC104.50 GBX-0.19Rating
CT UK Equity Alpha Inc Rtl Inc0.61 GBP0.26Rating
GSK PLC1,584.50 GBX0.06Rating
HSBC Holdings PLC638.80 GBX-0.90Rating
Imperial Brands PLC1,760.00 GBX0.66Rating
Invesco UK Equity Inc UK Inc1,285.16 GBP-0.31Rating
iShares UK Dividend ETF GBP Dist696.20 GBX-0.47Rating
Legal & General Group PLC243.70 GBX-0.53
Rio Tinto PLC Registered Shares5,325.00 GBX-0.86Rating
Schroder Income Acc117.90 GBP0.43Rating
Unilever PLC3,807.41 GBX0.99Rating

About Author

Emma Wall  is former Senior International Editor for Morningstar

© Copyright 2024 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Terms of Use        Privacy Policy        Modern Slavery Statement        Cookie Settings        Disclosures